Sex
Differences in Adolescent Depression: An Overview of Current Research
At some
point in many people’s lives, clinical depression may affect their
mental and physical well being, causing the world to seem bleak and
hopeless. Indeed, depression is much more common now than once
believed, with nearly eight percent of all Americans experiencing a
severe depressive episode that leaves them unable to function for weeks,
or even months. Symptoms of depression include loss of motivation,
profound sadness, low self-esteem, physical aches, feelings of
hopelessness, a loss of interest in most activities and difficulty
concentrating. This debilitating disorder affects all aspects of a
person’s life. However, women are much more affected by this disorder,
considering that women are almost twice as likely as men to develop
depressive symptoms (Nolen-Hoeksema, 1990).
This
apparent sex difference in depression seems to rise dramatically during
the adolescent years. Before the age of 11, girls and boys seem to have
fairly equal depressive rates; however, once girls enter adolescence,
they become much more depressed than boys do. In fact, by the age of
18, females have twice the depressive rate of males (Women’s Health
Weekly, 1998). According to Koenig (1994), the surging rates of female
adolescent depression continue to affect women throughout their
lifespan; it is suggested that if girls do not receive the necessary
treatment in adolescence, it is likely that their depressive symptoms
could continue into adulthood.
The
implications of the higher rate of female adolescent depression are
frightening. Girls are more likely than boys to seriously consider
suicide, as well as to attempt it. According to the 1995 Youth Risk
Behavior Surveillance, 30% of high school girls report seriously
considering suicide, compared to 18% of boys seriously considering
suicide (Phillips, 1998).
There also
seem to be racial and ethnic differences in female adolescent
depression. Asian girls appear to have the highest rate of depressive
symptoms, followed by Hispanic, Caucasian, and African-American girls.
In the same 1995 Youth Risk Behavior Surveillance study, Hispanic girls
had the highest rates of suicide consideration, followed by
African-American girls (Phillips, 1998).
Society’s
teenage girls seem to be facing a huge barrier to proper development and
happiness. According to The American Association of University Women
Educational Foundation (1998), adolescents’ responses to questionnaires
show that the adolescent years are a far more negative time for girls’
mental and physical health than boys’. Unfortunately, their depressive
episodes often go unnoticed by adults, because depressive symptoms are
often perceived as normal adolescent female moodiness (Phillips, 1998).
In other words, parents and teachers may notice that young girls seem
withdrawn, sad or apathetic, but attribute this behavior to female mood
swings that are supposed to be normal during adolescence. In fact,
females tend to show certain symptoms of depression more often than
boys, such as poor body image (Sands, 1998).
If adults
are to notice, and hopefully treat female adolescent depression, it is
necessary to know which factors contribute to the decline in her mental
well being in the first place. Many contributing factors that trigger
depressive episodes in both sexes could be partially to blame. For
example, poverty is a major contributing factor to adolescent depression
in general. Edelsohn et al. (1992) and Ialongo et al. (1993) used data
from the Baltimore Prevention Program Study, and found that, out of the
first graders studied, children from the impoverished neighborhoods had
higher mean depressive scores than children from more affluent
neighborhoods. Likewise, data from a randomly selected sample of 1,208
high school students found that both boys and girls in low socioeconomic
backgrounds are more susceptible to many stressors and support deficits,
therefore, possibly making them more vulnerable to depression (Gore et
al., 1992).
Similarly,
people from low socioeconomic environments are often exposed to more
violence, another possible contributor to depression. Aneshensel and
Sucoff summarized from their 1996 sample of 877 adolescents in Los
Angeles that youth in low socioeconomic status neighborhoods often
perceive their environments as being more dangerous than the youth in
high socioeconomic neighborhoods. Therefore, the more threatening the
adolescents’ perceptions of their home environments, the more common the
depressive symptoms. Also, Singer et al. (1995) found via a self-report
questionnaire issued to various high school students that violence
exposure variables explained a significant portion of variance in
depression.
Another
possible contributing factor may be parental depression, which may lead
to marital conflict and adversely affect skillful parenting, and
therefore contribute to maladjustment in the child. For example, Conger
et al. (1993) found that economic pressures could lead to depression in
parents, which negatively affects their parenting style. In turn, their
children’s adolescent adjustment is affected. Equally important, Downey
and Coyne (1990) reviewed various studies done on depressed parents, and
suggested that the children of depressed parents are at risk for many
adjustment problems, specifically clinical depression.